How this investor uses Book Value

By Morningstar |  03-09-20 | 

Vitaliy Katsenelson, chief executive officer at IMA, bought one of the best banks in the world for less than book value. Here he shares his insights.

Svenska Handelsbanken, based in Sweden, is one of the best-run banks in the world. Its greatness starts from how it is structured.

When we look at a financial company, we zoom in on its performance during a past financial crisis. The Great Recession was the ultimate stress test so far for financial firms being subjected to incredible pain. Svenska sailed through the crisis as if 2008 was just another year – its loan losses “spiked” from 0.1% to 0.2%. (By comparison, JP Morgan’s losses were 3.5% in 2008.)

Svenska is decentralized. The branches are responsible for their own profits and losses and underwriting decisions. Each branch strives to achieve above-average performance and thus pull up the profitability of the whole company. Svenska does not pay bonuses, and thus there are no short-term profit incentives. Instead, the employees are owners of the firm – they own about 10% through a special account funded by the company.

Svenska’s lending practices are very conservative. Loan-to-Value for Svenska-generated mortgages is 55%. House prices would have to drop 45% before Svenska would start losing money on mortgages. The coronavirus crisis may rival the magnitude of the Great Recession, but Svenska’s conservative lending practices and incredibly strong balance sheet should get us through the thick and thin without even minor scratches.

Svenska also pays a 7.5% dividend, which it has raised over time with earnings. In early March European governments asked all banks to suspend their dividends due to the coronavirus. They did not want to run into political issues like the airlines did in the U.S., where bailout money will go to plug the hole freshly created in companies’ balance sheets by share buybacks. Svenska complied (begrudgingly); however, it said that just as in any other banking crisis over the last fifty years, it would not need government assistance. It will not actually cancel its dividend but postpone the decision on paying it until fall 2020.

We wanted to own Svenska for a long time and finally got the opportunity. We bought one of the best banks in the world for less than book value, or less than 10 times earnings. Earnings will likely grow about 5% a year; and in addition, at some point Svenska’s valuation will come back to normal, increasing 50-80%. Svenska has historically traded at 1.5-1.8 times book.

What exactly is book value, or BV?

If you look at a company’s balance sheet, BV is the difference between the company’s assets and its liabilities – it is the company’s equity. We rarely use it as yardstick of value when we analyse nonfinancial companies, and for a good reason: a large chunk of the assets (and some of the liabilities) on a typical company’s financial statements are divorced from economic reality.

In the very, very old (manufacturing) economy, the cost of land and building a factory, less a company’s borrowings, was indicative of what the company’s equity (book value) was.

However, even then the BV measure was not without flaws, as it recorded the value of long-term assets (land, for instance) at cost. If land appreciated over the years, its value in the company’s financial statements did not change.

BV in today’s economy is even less relevant for most companies.

Take Apple, for instance: One of the most valuable companies in the world, it doesn’t even own its factories. The value that you don’t see on Apple’s balance sheet is that sparkle in Apple customers’ eyes when they use the company’s products. That sparkle is the intangible good that Apple created by building (often) revolutionary products. That good – Apple’s brand – is created by R&D (research and development) and marketing, and both of these expenses are income statement items and never make it to the balance sheet, at least not in a tangible, easily observable form.

To make things even more complicated, share buybacks are not kind to BV. Despite Apple’s earnings rising from $37 billion in 2013 to $57 billion in 2020, its BV declined from $123 billion to $78 billion over the same time period.

How could this happen?

Apple bought a few hundred billion dollars of its own stock in the open market and reduced its BV. We can keep going into the not-so-exciting weeds of BV, but we won’t –just trust us; share buybacks distort the BV of the company.

When we analyze Apple, along with many other things we pay close attention to its assets (mainly cash, accounts receivable, and inventories) and its liabilities (accounts payable and debt), but we pay little attention to its BV.

Financial companies are different beasts.

Their assets (loans) and liabilities (customer deposits and borrowings) must be marked to market (values) quarterly, and thus book value becomes a useful metric. At 1x book, we basically bought Svenska at its liquidation value and paid nothing for the company’s future ability to grow, its superior return on capital, its unique culture, etc. In other words, buying a poorly run bank at BV may or may not be a bargain, but buying one of the best-run banks in the world at BV is an incredible steal.

Add a Comment
Please login or register to post a comment.
Mutual Fund Tools
Ask Morningstar